10 Best Gym Flooring Options For Garages 2025 in the United States

The ProsourceFit Puzzle Exercise Mat is a versatile option for garage gym flooring. Made from high-density EVA foam, it offers excellent support and cushioning, making it ideal for protecting floors and providing a comfortable workout area. The ½-inch thickness provides adequate padding, and the interlocking design ensures easy assembly and disassembly.

The mat’s non-skid texture enhances safety by preventing slips, and its water-resistant nature makes it easy to clean using warm water and dish soap. This mat is durable and noise-reducing, which is beneficial in a gym setting or even for a children's play area. Covering 48 square feet with 12 tiles and including end borders for a polished look, it adequately meets the spatial needs of a home gym setup.

However, EVA foam may lack the durability of rubber mats, which could be a consideration for those with high-impact workout routines. The product's lightweight design (weighing only 4.4 pounds) makes it easy to move and store as needed. Potential users should consider the specific demands of their workout routines to ensure this mat meets their needs.

The ProsourceFit Extra Thick Puzzle Exercise Mat is a solid choice for gym flooring in garages, offering several key strengths. Made from high-density EVA foam, the material provides excellent support and cushioning, which is ideal for protecting floors from heavy gym equipment and providing comfort during workouts. The mats come in two thickness options, ¾ inch and 1 inch, which allows users to choose based on their specific needs for cushioning and protection.

The interlocking tiles are designed for easy assembly and disassembly, making them convenient for setting up and rearranging as needed. Additionally, the non-skid textured surface offers traction and safety, while the water-resistant and noise-reducing properties enhance the functionality. Cleaning is straightforward, although the mats require hand washing, which might be less convenient compared to machine-washable options.

On the downside, while EVA foam is durable, it may not be as long-lasting as rubber flooring under extremely heavy use. Also, depending on the size of the garage, users may need multiple packs to cover a larger area, which can add to the cost. However, with a limited lifetime warranty, it provides reassurance of quality and satisfaction.

The American Floor Mats Fit-Lock 3/8 Inch Heavy Duty Rubber Flooring is a solid choice for gym flooring in garages. Made from durable rubber, it effectively absorbs shock and impact, protecting both your equipment and your garage floor. The 3/8 inch thickness provides adequate cushioning without being overly bulky. The interlocking tile design makes it easy to install without needing adhesives, and the tiles fit together seamlessly, creating a smooth, finished look.

With 12 tiles in each set, you can cover a 6' x 8' area, which is a decent size for most home gym setups. The tiles are also versatile, with different pieces to cover corners, borders, and center areas effectively. Cleaning is straightforward—just wipe with a damp cloth or vacuum, and you’re all set. The solid black color is practical and will blend well with most garage interiors.

However, there are some drawbacks. The tiles may show dirt and dust more readily due to the solid black color, requiring frequent cleaning to maintain their appearance. Also, at 3/8 inch thickness, while sufficient for most uses, it might not provide enough cushioning for extremely heavy weights or high-impact activities. Despite these minor issues, the rubber is of high quality, and the ease of installation makes it a user-friendly option.