10 Best Automatic Yogurt Makers 2025 in the United States

The Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker stands out in the automatic yogurt makers category due to its adjustable temperature control and run time features. With a temperature range of 68-131°F and the ability to run for up to 48 hours, it allows precise control over the yogurt-making process, ensuring a high-quality probiotic yield. This machine is 100% BPA free, which is a significant advantage for health-conscious users.

It includes two large glass containers with BPA-free lids, adding to the convenience and safety of use. The ease of cleaning these glass containers is another plus point, making the maintenance straightforward. The product is also marketed as a wellness gift, which is appealing for those looking to support gut health, weight loss, collagen formation, and energy levels through homemade probiotics.

The promise of saving money by making probiotics at home is attractive, as it can be up to 90% cheaper than store-bought options. However, it is essential to consider its weight (5.39 pounds) and size (15.43 x 8.62 x 6.77 inches), which may require adequate counter space. Additionally, the claim of making trillions of probiotics is appealing, but users must ensure they have access to the right starter cultures. This yogurt maker is best suited for individuals or families looking to improve their gut health with homemade solutions and appreciate the convenience of customizable settings.

The Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1 is a versatile kitchen appliance that combines multiple cooking functions, including being an automatic yogurt maker. With a 6-quart capacity, it can accommodate the needs of growing families or those who like to meal prep. The stainless steel finish is not only fingerprint-resistant but also makes the unit easy to clean, with dishwasher-safe components like the lid and inner pot.

The touch controls and 13 customizable Smart Programs simplify cooking various dishes, including yogurt, ribs, soups, and more. This makes it user-friendly even for those who may not be tech-savvy. The appliance also comes with an app featuring over 800 recipes, which is great for culinary inspiration and convenience. Safety is a priority with over 10 safety features, including overheat protection and a safe-locking lid.

At 11.8 pounds, the Instant Pot Duo might be heavier and bulkier than single-function yogurt makers, which could be a drawback for those with limited kitchen space or who prefer a more lightweight device. Additionally, the multi-functionality might be overwhelming for individuals who only need a yogurt maker. Despite these points, the Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1 is a robust option for those who appreciate versatility and efficiency in their kitchen appliances.

The Instant Pot Pro (8 QT) 10-in-1 Pressure Cooker is a versatile kitchen appliance that also functions as a yogurt maker. With a generous 8-quart capacity, it is ideal for larger families or those who enjoy meal prepping. One of its standout features is the cookware-grade stainless steel inner pot, which ensures efficient heating and durability. This pot can also be used on the stovetop, adding to its versatility.

The appliance includes safety features like overheat protection, a safe locking lid, and a gentle steam release switch to prevent countertop splashes and reduce noise. The programmable settings provide convenience, including five customizable settings and 28 preset programs for various cooking needs. When making yogurt, the user can benefit from the precise temperature control to ensure consistent results. The included app with over 800 recipes is a helpful bonus for exploring new dishes.

The Instant Pot Pro's multiple functions might be overwhelming for someone specifically looking for an automatic yogurt maker, and its relatively large size may not be suitable for small kitchens. Additionally, while the inner pot is dishwasher safe, cleaning the appliance's other parts may require extra effort. The Instant Pot Pro (8 QT) is an excellent choice for those seeking a multi-functional appliance that includes yogurt making, but it may be a bit complex for users wanting a simple, dedicated yogurt maker.