10 Best Cat Litter Tray 2025 in the United States

The PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Reusable Tray is a compact and convenient option for cat owners seeking an alternative to disposable trays. It's designed to work with the PetSafe ScoopFree Original and Ultra Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes, making it particularly suitable for those who already use these systems. The tray includes 4.3 pounds of premium non-clumping crystal litter, which excels in odor control by absorbing urine and drying solid waste faster than traditional clumping clay litter. This feature can be especially beneficial in small spaces or multi-cat households, ensuring a fresh and clean environment.

The tray's rounded corners and edges simplify the cleaning process, promoting a healthier setting for your cat. Its durable plastic construction ensures longevity, and the stainless-steel magnets help secure the waste shield to lock in odors effectively. Additionally, using this reusable tray won't void the warranty of your automatic litter box system, offering peace of mind.

However, there are a few drawbacks. The tray's small size (21.75 x 14.5 x 2.5 inches) may not be ideal for larger cats or those who prefer more space. Also, while the tray is easy to clean, some users might find the initial cost of the crystal litter refills to be higher compared to traditional litter. If you prioritize odor control and ease of use, the PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Reusable Tray is a strong contender for maintaining a pleasant and clean home environment for your feline friend.

The Arm & Hammer Cat Box for Indoor Cats with Microban is designed to simplify litter maintenance with its patented lift-to-sift technology, eliminating the need for scooping. This feature is particularly beneficial for users looking for ease of cleaning. The built-in Microban protection offers maximum odor control, making it suitable for indoor use where managing odors is crucial.

The tray is versatile, compatible with various types of litter such as pine, crystal, pellets, and clumping cat litter, providing users flexibility in choosing their preferred litter type. The box is made from recycled materials in the USA, which can appeal to environmentally conscious buyers. Measuring 19 x 15 x 8 inches, it provides a comfortable space for cats, adhering to the guideline of being 1.5 times longer than the cat itself.

However, the sides are only 8 inches high, which might not be sufficient for cats that tend to kick litter out of the tray. The product's plastic material makes it lightweight but may not be as durable as heavier-duty options. This litter tray is ideal for indoor cat owners looking for a convenient and odor-controlling solution, but may require regular replacement every 12 months to maintain its effectiveness. The sifting functionality and ease of cleaning are standout features, though the height of the sides might be a minor drawback depending on your cat's habits.

The PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro Automatic Self Cleaning Cat Litter Box measures 27.6x19.1x16 inches, making it suitable for most indoor spaces. It features automatic cleaning that saves you from the daily hassle of scooping and changing litter, a major plus for busy pet owners. The use of crystal litter is particularly effective at controlling odors, as it absorbs urine and dehydrates solid waste, keeping your home smelling fresh. The litter box is also designed to be mess-free, with low-tracking crystals and a hooded cover to minimize litter scatter.

Additionally, the health counter helps you monitor your cat's usage and health, which can be an invaluable tool for early detection of potential health issues. One disposable tray is included, but ongoing use requires purchasing additional crystal litter trays, which can add up in costs. Some users have noted that the crystal litter can be more expensive compared to traditional clumping litter.

The unit weighs 20.3 pounds and is relatively easy to set up, but moving it around frequently might be cumbersome due to its weight. It is a well-designed, convenient option for cat owners looking for an automated, low-maintenance solution, but be prepared for the recurring cost of crystal litter and trays.