10 Best Cookie Sheets 2025 in the United States

The Calphalon Premium Nonstick Baking Pans Set includes two 12x17 inch cookie sheets, which are versatile for a variety of baking needs. Made from heavy gauge steel, these pans offer durability and even heating, which is essential for consistent baking results. The interlocking nonstick layers ensure enhanced performance, making food release and cleanup easier compared to standard nonstick bakeware.

Raised edges on the pans prevent spills, making them suitable for everything from cookies to sheet cakes, and their dishwasher-safe feature adds convenience to the cleanup process. Additionally, the set is backed by a lifetime warranty, providing assurance of its quality. However, at a weight of 4.34 pounds, the pans might be slightly heavier than some users expect.

The Calphalon set performs well in the essential aspects of material quality, size, and functionality, making it a reliable choice for those looking for durable and efficient baking sheets.

The Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminum Commercial Half Sheet is a solid choice for anyone looking to elevate their baking game. Made from pure natural aluminum, these cookie sheets excel in heat conductivity, ensuring your cookies and other baked goods brown evenly. The reinforced steel rim adds durability and prevents warping, which is an excellent feature for heavy-duty use. With an exterior size of 17.9 x 12.9 inches, they fit well in standard ovens and are great for various recipes, from cookies to sheet pan dinners. Plus, the fact that they are made in the USA since 1946 speaks to their quality and reliability.

However, there are a few things to keep in mind. Firstly, they are not dishwasher safe, so you’ll need to hand wash them, which might be a downside for those preferring low-maintenance options. Additionally, while the aluminum is rust-resistant, it can still be prone to staining if not cared for properly. Some users might also find them a bit heavier compared to other materials, which may be a consideration for those looking for lightweight alternatives.

The Nordic Ware cookie sheets are particularly suited for home bakers who value durability and consistent results in their baking endeavors. If you’re in need of reliable cookie sheets that promise longevity and quality, these are a great investment.

The GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set offers a versatile trio of baking sheets in small, medium, and large sizes. Made from durable carbon steel, these pans promise to resist warping and scratching, ensuring long-lasting use in your kitchen. Their heavy-duty gauge promotes even heat distribution, leading to consistently baked goods. The nonstick coating is a standout feature, designed to provide easy food release and simplify cleanup. Although dishwasher safe, hand washing is recommended to extend their lifespan.

The rims on these pans help contain food and prevent spills, making them practical for various baking tasks. The dark gray color might affect baking times slightly, as darker surfaces can absorb more heat. Suitable for everyday baking needs, this set is particularly appealing to home bakers seeking reliable and easy-to-maintain bakeware. However, those who prefer extremely thick or rimless sheets might need to explore other options.