10 Best Energy Star Toaster Oven 2025 in the United States

The Cuisinart Air Fryer + Convection Toaster Oven (TOA-70) is a versatile kitchen appliance that combines multiple cooking functions into one unit. It offers an impressive array of cooking options such as air frying, baking, broiling, grilling, toasting, and warming. With a wide temperature range from 250°F to 450°F and an adjustable temperature dial, it can handle a variety of recipes.

Its large capacity can accommodate six slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, or even a 4-pound chicken, making it suitable for small families or individuals who enjoy cooking different meals without needing multiple appliances. The 60-minute timer and auto-shutoff feature add convenience and safety, while the toast shade selector allows for personalized toasting preferences. The stainless steel finish gives it a sleek appearance that fits well in modern kitchens.

Additionally, the included oven rack, baking pan, AirFry basket, and grill make it a complete package for various cooking needs. The nonstick interior ensures that cleaning up is relatively easy, which is a big plus for busy households. However, at 23.1 pounds, it is relatively heavy, which might be a concern for those with limited counter space or who need to move it frequently. The knob control system might not be as intuitive for users accustomed to digital controls. Additionally, since it's a corded electric appliance, it might limit placement options in the kitchen based on the proximity to power outlets. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Cuisinart TOA-70 is a highly functional and energy-efficient appliance with a solid 4.5-star rating from users, making it a reliable choice for those in need of a multi-functional toaster oven.

The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900BSS stands out for its versatility and capacity. It measures 17.5 inches in depth, 21.5 inches in width, and 12.7 inches in height, making it sizable enough to fit a 14-pound turkey or a 12-cup muffin tray. With 13 cooking functions including toast, bake, air fry, and dehydrate, it caters to a wide range of culinary needs.

The Element iQ System with five independent quartz elements ensures precise cooking by eliminating cold spots, and the super convection technology speeds up cooking by up to 30%, perfect for those who value efficiency. The oven also includes useful accessories like a pizza pan, two oven racks, and a mesh basket for air frying and dehydrating. The digital LCD display simplifies operation, showing pre-heat completion and countdown timers for accurate cooking results.

Its larger size may be a downside for small kitchens or limited counter space. The brushed stainless steel finish can show fingerprints, requiring more frequent cleaning to maintain its look. Additionally, while the unit is energy-efficient, its 1800-watt power consumption might be on the higher side for some users. The interior light and adjustable rack are practical features, but the oven's complexity might require a learning curve for those less familiar with advanced kitchen appliances. The two-year limited warranty provides some peace of mind for buyers. This toaster oven is ideal for large families or avid home cooks who need a multi-functional, high-capacity appliance.

The Breville BOV845BSS Smart Oven Pro is a versatile and high-performing countertop toaster oven. Its compact dimensions (14.5"D x 18.5"W x 11"H) suit most kitchen countertops, and its 5 independent quartz elements with smart algorithms ensure efficient heat distribution. With an 1800-watt power and convection feature, it reduces cooking time by up to 30%. This oven provides 10 cooking functions, covering all bases from toasting and baking to slow cooking and reheating, making it a multi-functional tool for various cooking needs.

The slow cook function is particularly notable, allowing for up to 10 hours of cooking at low temperatures, ideal for tenderizing meats and developing complex flavors. The oven also includes practical accessories like an enamel broiling rack, baking pan, and non-stick pizza pan, which add to its convenience and usability. An interior oven light and LCD display make it easier to monitor cooking progress and navigate settings. The brushed stainless steel finish gives it a modern and sleek appearance, fitting well with contemporary kitchen designs. However, weighing 22.8 pounds, it might be cumbersome to move around frequently.

The oven’s energy efficiency is bolstered by the convection feature, but its 1800-watt power might still be a consideration for energy-conscious users. Cleaning is relatively straightforward with a removable crumb tray and replaceable componentry. Safety features include auto shut-off and an indicator light, enhancing its user-friendliness. A one-year limited warranty provides some peace of mind. The price point might be higher than some other models, but its performance, versatility, and reliability make it a strong contender for those looking to invest in a quality toaster oven.