10 Best Eyeliner Pencils 2025 in the United States

Julep's When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Pencil in Rich Brown offers a versatile and long-lasting option for eyeliner enthusiasts. As a sharpenable pencil, it combines the ease of a traditional pencil with the smooth application of a gel, making it suitable for both top lash lines and waterlines. The highly pigmented formula ensures intense, saturated color that stays put for over 10 hours, which is ideal for long days or nights out.

The matte finish of the Rich Brown shade provides a sophisticated look that can be easily smudged for a smoky effect before it sets. With over 20 shades available in both matte and shimmer finishes, there are plenty of options to suit different preferences and occasions. Ophthalmologist-tested, it is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

However, as it requires a separate sharpener, it may be less convenient for those who prefer twist-up pencils. Additionally, its creamy texture, while smooth, may require a light touch to avoid breakage. This eyeliner is a great choice for anyone seeking a reliable, high-performing pencil with a variety of color options.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil in Smokin Topaz offers a convenient retractable design, eliminating the need for a sharpener. This makes it user-friendly, especially for those who appreciate a hassle-free application. The creamy formula is highly pigmented, delivering the intensity of a liquid eyeliner but with the ease of a pencil. Users can expect a smooth and comfortable application that glides on effortlessly.

Additionally, the eyeliner is smudge-proof, ensuring that your look stays intact throughout the day, even in humid conditions. This makes it an excellent choice for long wear and active lifestyles. The product is available in a range of shades, from natural to more vivid options, allowing for versatile looks. Another notable strength is that it’s cruelty-free, aligning with the ethical values of many consumers.

It is important to note that the product has been discontinued by the manufacturer, which might make it difficult to find in the future. For those looking for a reliable, easy-to-use, and long-lasting eyeliner with a creamy finish, this NYX pencil is a strong contender, provided you can still find it in stock.

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in 202 Black Brown is designed for those seeking a long-lasting eyeliner. Its standout feature is its waterproof formula, which promises up to 24-hour wear, making it ideal for all-day use without needing frequent touch-ups. The eyeliner offers a smooth, creamy application, which is great for creating a variety of looks, from sharp, precise lines to more blended, smoky eyes.

The built-in sharpener is a practical addition, ensuring you can maintain a fine tip for detailed work without needing an extra tool. Additionally, the built-in smudger helps in softening lines for a more dramatic effect, offering versatility in styling your eyes. The product comes in 8 intense shades, providing options for different preferences and occasions.

The specified finish is metallic, which might not suit everyone's taste, especially those preferring a matte look. Some users might find the crayon form less precise compared to liquid eyeliners. While the product dimensions indicate it is lightweight and portable, some may find the 0.01 oz size small, especially if used daily. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a strong choice for those prioritizing longevity and versatility in their eye makeup routine.