10 Best Eyeliners 2025 in the United States

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a pencil-type eyeliner in black, designed to offer a bold, long-lasting look. Its major strengths include a waterproof formula that claims to last up to 24 hours and a smooth, creamy texture, making application easy.

The built-in sharpener is a handy feature, ensuring you always have a precise tip, and the smudger allows for versatile looks ranging from sharp and defined to soft and smoky. Available in eight intense shades, this eyeliner is ophthalmologist-tested, which is reassuring for those with sensitive eyes. The matte finish adds to its appeal for a classic look.

Some users may find the claim of 24-hour wear slightly exaggerated depending on their skin type or activity level. Being a pencil, it might require frequent sharpening to maintain the desired precision. Despite these minor drawbacks, it is a solid choice for anyone seeking a reliable, versatile eyeliner that can handle various makeup looks with ease.

The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Micro Tip in Intense Black is designed to create beautifully defined eyes. This eyeliner features a micro tip that allows for precise application, making it easier to achieve fine lines and detailed looks. The color is a rich, intense black which can provide a striking and bold appearance.

Its glossy finish adds a touch of shine to your eye makeup, giving it a polished look. The formula is designed to glide on smoothly, ensuring that it doesn’t skip, smudge, or pull on the skin, which makes the application process easier and more comfortable. It is also quick-drying, preventing any accidental smudges right after application.

One of the standout features is its longevity; it is touted to last all day without fading, making it a reliable choice for long wear. Being a liquid eyeliner in pencil form may require some practice for those who are not accustomed to using this type. Also, the glossy finish might not appeal to everyone, as some users may prefer a matte look. Nonetheless, it's an excellent option for anyone seeking a dependable and intense black eyeliner that stays put throughout the day.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil in Smokin Topaz offers several appealing features. This retractable eyeliner is designed for ease of use, eliminating the need for sharpening. Its creamy formula provides intense pigment coverage similar to a liquid eyeliner and holds for hours, making it ideal for creating bold, defined eye looks.

The eyeliner is available in a variety of shades, from natural to bright, allowing for a range of creative possibilities. Additionally, its smudge-proof feature ensures that your eyeliner stays in place throughout the day, even in heat and humidity, which is a significant advantage for long-lasting wear. This product is also cruelty-free, aligning with ethical beauty standards and being certified by PETA, meaning it hasn't been tested on animals.

Despite these strengths, there are a few potential drawbacks. The finish is creamy, which may not be suitable for those who prefer a matte or glossy finish. Furthermore, the product is discontinued by the manufacturer, which could make it difficult to find in the future. The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil is a solid choice for anyone seeking a reliable, long-lasting, and easy-to-use eyeliner in a rich brown shade.