10 Best Puppy Teething Toys 2026 in the United States

The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack Maplestick/Zaggler chew toys are designed specifically for small teething puppies under 15 pounds. Made with a softer nylon material compared to adult chew toys, these are gentle enough to soothe tender puppy teeth without being too hard. The size is small and lightweight, making it easy for little pups to grip and chew comfortably.

What stands out is the use of real food ingredients for flavor — the Zaggler is infused with real bacon scent, while the Maplestick includes real maple wood, which helps keep puppies interested and encourages healthy chewing habits. Safety is a key point: these toys aren’t edible, so puppies should be supervised during play, and the toys should be replaced if damaged. Since they are tiny, they’re best kept away from larger dogs to avoid accidental swallowing.

Made in the USA, this pack comes with two different shapes that offer varied textures to keep chewing fun and engaging. While the toys are durable for gentle chewers, aggressive chewers might wear them down faster. If you have a small puppy who loves to chew and needs something safe and flavorful to help with teething, these are a reliable and thoughtfully designed choice.

The Benebone 2 Count Wishbone/Dental Dog Chew Toys are designed with durability and flavor in mind, making them suitable for small breed puppies and dogs at all life stages. Made from tough nylon material, these chews are stronger than real bones and can last for weeks, which is great for puppies who are often heavy chewers during teething. The real bacon flavor is a big plus, as it helps keep puppies interested and encourages them to chew on the toy rather than household items.

The curved wishbone and dental shapes are designed for easy gripping, recognizing that dogs don’t have thumbs, which helps a puppy manage the toy comfortably. The size is small, suitable for little mouths, but might not be ideal for larger breeds or very aggressive chewers. In terms of safety, nylon is generally safe but can wear down and create small pieces, so supervision is recommended to avoid choking hazards. These toys are made in the USA and backed by a customer satisfaction guarantee, which adds confidence in quality and support.

Because the texture is quite hard, puppies with sensitive gums might find it a bit tough at first. If you’re looking for a durable, flavorful chew toy for a small puppy that enjoys chewing to ease teething discomfort, Benebone offers a reliable and well-reviewed option.

The KONG Classic Stuffable Dog Toy is a popular choice for small dogs, especially puppies who are teething. Made from durable natural rubber, it offers a safe and chew-friendly texture that helps satisfy puppies' instinctual chewing needs without breaking apart easily. Its small size (about 3 x 1.75 inches) fits well in little mouths, making it a practical option for small breeds.

One of the standout features is its hollow center, which allows you to fill it with treats like peanut butter or kibble. This not only keeps puppies engaged longer but also provides mental stimulation, which is great for reducing boredom and destructive chewing. The erratic bounce of the toy adds an element of fun during playtime, encouraging physical activity. Being dishwasher safe simplifies cleaning, which is helpful for hygiene.

This toy is best suited for average chewers; very aggressive chewers might wear it down faster. Also, since it’s made from rubber, some puppies might need supervision initially to ensure they don't chew off pieces. It is a reliable, veterinarian-recommended option that balances safety, durability, and entertainment for teething puppies, especially those of smaller breeds.