We Use CookiesWe use cookies to enhance the security, performance, functionality and for analytical and promotional activities. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our privacy policy

All Categories

Toys & Games

Stuffed Animals & Plush Toys

Rarest Beanie Babies

10 Best Rarest Beanie Babies 2025 in the United States

From leading brands and best sellers available on the web.

Winner

Ty - Beanie Boo's - Meadow The Fox Soft Toy, 15 cm, Tricolour, TY36379

9.9

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellie Mitch a Brown Otter - 6"

9.8

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellies Lillibelle The Pink Kitten with Blue Glitter Eyes, Cuddly Plush Animals with Soft Belly Original 20 cm T41283

9.6

score

View on Amazon

JANGANNSA

JANGANNSA Winter Knit Baby Hat Twist Warm Beanie for Boys Girls Infant Toddler Baby Beanie with Pompom (0-6 Months,Ivory White)

9.4

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellies – Jenny The Multicoloured Kitten with Glitter Blue Eyes, Original Plush Animals with Soft Belly 20 cm – T41291

9.2

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellie Penelope The Pink Pig - 6"

9.0

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellie Bumper - The Hedgehog 6"

8.7

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Baby Scarlett -White Valentine Bear - 6"

8.4

score

View on Amazon

Ty Beanie Bellie BINX Blue Russian cat - 6"", 41501

8.2

score

View on Amazon

#10

TY 50052 Beanie Babies Fredrick Fox, Multicoloured

7.9

score

View on Amazon

More products we considered

Ditucu Cute Capybara Plush with Happy Hat Red Bow Soft Capybara Stuffed Animals Plushies Toys for Birthday Gifts Party Decoration for Kids Brown 9 inch

View Deal

Jolitee Recovery Bear Gifts for Kids and Adults, Teddy Broken Arm Broken Leg, Get Well Stuffed Animal Teddy Bear with Left or Right Arm Cast Sling 10.5 inches (Doctor Nurse Pink)

View Deal

Jolitee My First Bear Stuffed Animal - Beige Plush Bear 15"

View Deal

Squishmallows Original 12-Inch Legacy The Bunnycorn - Official Jazwares Valentine's Day Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Bunny Unicorn Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

View Deal

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Simon The Orange Sloth - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Sloth Stuffed Animal Toy - Add to Your Squad - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

View Deal

How do we rank products for you?

Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

10 Best Rarest Beanie Babies 2025 in the United States

Ty - Beanie Boo's - Meadow The Fox Soft Toy, 15 cm, Tricolour, TY36379

Ty Beanie Bellie Mitch a Brown Otter - 6"

Ty Beanie Bellies Lillibelle The Pink Kitten with Blue Glitter Eyes, Cuddly Plush Animals with Soft Belly Original 20 cm T41283

JANGANNSA Winter Knit Baby Hat Twist Warm Beanie for Boys Girls Infant Toddler Baby Beanie with Pompom (0-6 Months,Ivory White)

Ty Beanie Bellies – Jenny The Multicoloured Kitten with Glitter Blue Eyes, Original Plush Animals with Soft Belly 20 cm – T41291

Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Caparinne The Pink Bigfoot - Official Jazwares Valentine's Day Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Add to Your Squad - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

PixieCrush Unicorn Cat Plushie - Mommy Cat Unicorn with 4 Baby Kittens - Magical Cat Pillow Plushies for Girls Ages 3-8 - Big Unicorn Stuffed Animals - Ideal Gift for Girls 5 x 10 x 8 inches

Jolitee Big Brother Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, Big Brother Gifts for Toddler Boy Plush Toys, 12 Inches

CLOVERCAT Weighted Dog Plush, Weighted Stuffed Animals, Throw Pillow, Stuffed Animal for Kids, Cuddle Pillow, Cute Plushies, Weighted Animal Plush, Kids Toy, Soft, Warm & Comfortable, Plush Pillow

Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Omar The Bear - Official Jazwares Valentine's Day Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Toy - Add to Your Squad - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

Ty Beanie Bellie Penelope The Pink Pig - 6"

Ty Beanie Bellie Bumper - The Hedgehog 6"

Ty Beanie Baby Scarlett -White Valentine Bear - 6"

Ty Beanie Bellie BINX Blue Russian cat - 6"", 41501

TY 50052 Beanie Babies Fredrick Fox, Multicoloured

TY Beanie Boos Rare Beanie Babies

McDonald's Rare Beanie Babies

Rare Beanie Babies

Rarest Beanie Boos

TY Rare Beanie Babies

Ditucu Cute Capybara Plush with Happy Hat Red Bow Soft Capybara Stuffed Animals Plushies Toys for Birthday Gifts Party Decoration for Kids Brown 9 inch

Jolitee Recovery Bear Gifts for Kids and Adults, Teddy Broken Arm Broken Leg, Get Well Stuffed Animal Teddy Bear with Left or Right Arm Cast Sling 10.5 inches (Doctor Nurse Pink)

Jolitee My First Bear Stuffed Animal - Beige Plush Bear 15"

Squishmallows Original 12-Inch Legacy The Bunnycorn - Official Jazwares Valentine's Day Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Bunny Unicorn Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Simon The Orange Sloth - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Sloth Stuffed Animal Toy - Add to Your Squad - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys